The church is not open to the public during regular, ongoing hours of operation; however, curious visitors can take a stroll around the grounds on their own or attend a scheduled event to see the interior of the church.
Built between 1753 and 1767, Fort Herkimer Church is one of the oldest churches in New York State and the oldest building in Herkimer County. It serves as a reminder of days past, having functioned as both a fortress during the French and Indian War and American Revolution as well as a place of worship for valley settlers.